A quiet student isn't a bad student. Some people say little in any language. Others have plenty to say but get stuck between the idea and the English. Online it's harder still: there's a delay, a camera, and fewer of the small signals that tell someone it's their turn. Most of the fixes below are small, and you can try them in your next lesson.
Why some adult students don't talk
- They don't have the words for the topic, so they say nothing rather than say it badly.
- They're afraid of mistakes, especially if they were corrected a lot at school, or if they're senior at work and not used to sounding unsure.
- They're used to classrooms where the teacher talks and students answer only when asked.
- The question is too big or too closed. "What do you think about technology?" is too big. "Do you like your job?" gets "Yes."
- The tutor fills every silence, so the student learns to wait.
- They're tired. Many adults come to a lesson after a full day of work.
- The online setting gets in the way: they aren't sure when to speak, the delay cuts them off, or they don't like seeing themselves on screen.
- The topic means nothing to them.
To find out which it is, ask at the end of a lesson: "Today, was it hard to find the words, or did you not know what to say about the topic?" The two answers need different fixes.
Questions that get longer answers
Ask open questions
Yes/no questions get one word. Small changes get sentences:
- "Did you have a good weekend?" becomes "What did you do on Saturday?"
- "Do you like cooking?" becomes "What do you cook when friends come over?"
- "Is your city nice?" becomes "What would you show me if I visited your city?"
Start with experience, then opinion
"Tell me about the last time you…" is easier than "What do you think about…?" A story comes from memory. An opinion has to be built. Before "Is online shopping bad for small stores?", ask "What was the last thing you bought online? Why not in a store?" The opinion question is easier after that.
Give a choice at lower levels
"Do you prefer mornings or evenings?" gives the student the words. Add "Why?" and you get a sentence.
Follow up
Most of the talking comes from the second question, not the first:
- "Why?"
- "What happened next?"
- "Can you give me an example?"
- "What did your boss say?"
Repeating a word with a questioning voice also works:
- Student: It was a disaster.
- Tutor: A disaster?
- Student: Yes, the hotel lost our booking, and we slept in the car.
Avoid "Do you understand?" and "Any questions?" Both get a polite "Yes" or "No."
Give them time
After you ask a question, wait. Count to five in your head, and add a second or two for the delay on a video call. Don't rephrase right away: each new version makes the student start thinking again.
If the silence goes on, say "Take your time," or "Think for a moment, then tell me." For a bigger question, give a minute to make notes first. Three words written down are often enough to get a quiet student started.
Make it about them
Students talk most about their own lives. Use their job, their children, their city, their hobbies and the show they're watching. Ask them to hold up a photo from their phone and tell you about it.
Turn textbook questions into their questions. If the book asks "Have you ever been to Japan?", ask about a place they've actually been. Remember details and bring them back the next week: "How did your daughter's exam go?"
Give them the words first
- Teach five or six words before the speaking task, not after.
- Keep sentence starters on screen: I think… It depends on… I'm not sure, but… The main reason is…
- Answer the question yourself first, in two or three sentences. That gives a model, but keep it short so it doesn't become a speech.
Role-plays
Role-plays suit quiet students because they speak as someone else, and the language is easy to predict.
- Give a clear situation and a goal: "You bought a jacket online and it's the wrong size. Call the store. You want your money back, not a store credit."
- Give two or three minutes to prepare, with useful phrases on screen.
- Take the harder role yourself, and add one small problem for the student to solve.
- Do it twice. The second try is usually smoother and longer, and the student can hear the difference.
- Use situations from their life: a call with a client, a doctor's appointment, a complaint to a landlord.
Debates
Give the student a side. Defending an opinion that isn't theirs takes away the personal risk.
- Keep topics small and concrete: cats or dogs, a four-day work week, phones at the dinner table.
- Give three minutes to write three reasons.
- Let the student go first, and answer each reason with one of your own. Then swap sides.
- Give phrases for disagreeing: I see your point, but… That's true, but what about…? I'm not sure that's right, because…
Picture tasks
A picture gives a quiet student something to look at, and many of the words they need are right in front of them.
- Start with what they can see: "What's happening? Who are these people? Where are they?"
- Move to guessing: "What happened just before? What will happen next? What is she thinking?"
- Compare two pictures: a small city apartment and a big house in the country. "Which would you choose? Why?"
- Use their own photos, which bring stories with them.
How much should the tutor talk?
There's no exact ratio. In a one-to-one lesson where the student wants to speak, they should talk more than you do. Watch for these signs that you're talking too much:
- You explain for more than a minute or two at a time.
- You answer your own questions.
- You finish the student's sentences.
- Your follow-up is longer than their answer.
With the student's permission, record a lesson and listen to ten minutes of it. It's the quickest way to hear your own talking time.
Correct less during speaking tasks, too. Stopping a quiet student to fix a past tense can end the conversation. Note the mistakes and go through two or three at the end.
If you teach on SnappySchool, write the sentence starters on the whiteboard at the start of the task, so they stay in view while the student talks.
Library lessons that get students talking
These lessons from the SnappySchool library are built toward a speaking task, such as a debate, an interview, a game or a role-play, and each downloads as a PDF:
- Grammar: comparatives (A2): two sisters compare weather, rent and traffic on a Sunday call, and the lesson ends with a friendly debate: summer or winter, cats or dogs.
- Agreeing: So do I. Neither can I. (A2 grammar): the closing game is to find five things the student and the teacher share. Good for a student who isn't ready for long answers yet.
- What kind of person are you? (B1): an introvert describes her extrovert twin, and the lesson ends with a personality interview.
- Fast fashion and cheap clothes (B1): linkers like however and as a result, ending in a debate on taxing fast fashion.
- Formula One racing (B2): contrast and purpose linkers, and a debate on the sport's cost and risks.
- Building confidence (B2): a man learns to speak up in meetings, and the student coaches the teacher before a speech.
Questions
What do I do when a student gives one-word answers?
Change the question, not the student. Swap yes/no questions for open ones, ask a follow-up every time, and give a model answer first. At lower levels, give a choice and then ask "Why?"
How long should I wait after asking a question?
Count to five in your head, and add a second or two on a video call because of the delay. If nothing comes, say "Take your time" before you rephrase.
Should I let a quiet student use their own language?
A word or two when they're stuck is fine. Give them the English, then ask them to say the whole sentence again. It keeps them talking instead of giving up.
What if my student doesn't want to turn on the camera?
Camera off can help a nervous student at first, and you can still hear how they speak. But you lose their face, so you can't see when they're about to say something. Agree to try the camera for part of the lesson, such as role-plays.