Thinking for yourself

  • B2 · Upper-intermediate
  • Topic lesson
  • 60 min

Why we believe what we already think, what Dewey meant by careful thinking, how fact-checkers read the web, and the limits of being critical. Ten words for thinking and truth, and hedging: tend to, may, seem, probably, studies suggest.

Free, no card needed. The PDF has every slide, the homework and an answer key.

What's in the lesson

  1. 1Warm-up
  2. 2In this lesson
  3. 3Guess the words (1)Vocabulary exercise
  4. 4Guess the words (2)Vocabulary exercise
  5. 5Check the wordsVocabulary
  6. 6Check your understandingReading comprehension
  7. 7Listen: Rachel's juryListening comprehension
  8. 8Use the new wordsVocabulary exercise
  9. 9What does it mean?Grammar exercise
  10. 10Hedging: making a claim carefulGrammar rule
  11. 11Make it carefulGrammar exercise
  12. 12Say it naturallySpeaking practice
  13. 13Is it true?Speaking practice
  14. 14Let's discussDiscussion
  15. 15Wrap-up

Homework

  1. 1Homework: closest meaningVocabulary exercise
  2. 2Homework: your sentencesVocabulary exercise
  3. 3Homework: hedgingGrammar exercise
  4. 4Homework: check a claimDiscussion

Words

Two slides from the lesson

Warm-up

Let's talk about thinking.

  1. Have you ever been tricked by a fake photo or video? What happened?
  2. Do you make decisions quickly, or do you like to think for a long time?
  3. Who do you trust most when you need advice: friends, experts or the internet?

Grammar rule

Hedging: making a claim careful

Hedging means making a claim softer or more careful, so that it says only what the evidence shows.

ToolExample
may / might / could + verbThis may explain the delay.
seem / appear + to + verb, or It seems / appears (that)…The plan seems to be working. It appears that the file was deleted.
seem / appear + to have + past participle (about the past)The fire seems to have started in the kitchen.
tend to + verbOlder drivers tend to drive more slowly.
be likely / unlikely to + verb, It's likely (that)…Prices are likely to rise. It's unlikely that she'll win.
adverbs: probably, possibly, perhaps, apparentlyThe bridge was probably built in the 1800s.
suggest / indicateThe results suggest that sleep helps memory.

Words like some, many, often and usually also make a claim smaller: Some studies show… Older cars often use more gas.

Word order: probably usually goes after be and after helping verbs like will, but before a main verb and before a negative short form: It will probably snow. She probably knows. It probably won't snow. In American English, likely is also used like probably: He'll likely be late. For a possible "no", use may not or might not: It may not be true. (It couldn't be true means that it is impossible.)

Hedging is useful in essays, discussions and polite disagreement ("I tend to think…", "It seems to me that…", "I'd say…"). But don't hedge everything: when the evidence is strong, say so clearly.

Teach it live with video and a whiteboard, or print it: the PDF has every slide, the homework and the answers.

Teach this lesson